A faithful reader responded to my request for Swing Shift ideas on yesterday’s post, but asked to remain anonymous, so you’ll just have to guess who might have written the following:

So I’ve got this friend who is currently in a relationship. He has, for the entirety of the relationship and for the foreseeable future, cheated on her with many, many, many people (present company possibly included).  Anyway, the girlfriend really doesn’t know, or if she does, thinks it’s only been one or two people in the early part of their relationship. She is not down with sharing him. She also believes they will someday get married. He knows this will not happen.

So that’s the backstory. The real question is that he would prefer to be in an open relationship or swinging situation (easier than lying and cheating!). That’s what he wants for a marriage or long-term partnership. Being the helpful person I am, I’m wondering how he could possibly meet other like-minded people. Are the swinger websites welcoming to singles looking for other singles? Or is it more of a place for the already coupled? I doubt he’d go to a specialized club or event on his own, so the options are probably limited on that front. I can see him thriving in an open relationship, it’s just a matter of getting him into one first.

Thoughts?

Oh boy, I guess it’s time to direct readers to my Marriage and Infidelity post, which generated some rather heated discussion in the comments. [It kinda sucked to read those comments again, I feel like I lost a friend because of that post.]  Read the post and I think you’ll get an idea how I feel about this man’s intentions where his girlfriend and a possible future marriage are concerned.

More to the point for Swing Shift, the key question is, how does a single guy find a single woman who is interested in swinging as well?  Damned if I know!

Let’s first consider the sheer number disadvantage a guy is up against in the lifestyle.  I did a search on Swappernet first for single men within 25 miles of my zip code, ages 25-45, no other limits on the search and turned up 117 results.  Then, I repeated the search, looking for a woman and only turned up 17 results.  117/17, that’s a 7:1 single male to single female ratio.  Not exactly good odds.

Veronica: There are some ‘gangbang’ groups around here that look for single men, but I think that a guy would have better luck getting 50 yard line tickets for the Patriots than getting into that group.  I also think that your friend does not want to share woman with half a dozen guys at the same time.

I’ll admit a bias against younger couples and/or couples that haven’t been together very long who are in the lifestyle.  I’ve read and heard numerous other swingers and poly types talk about the strength of the primary relationship being critical to being able to share one’s partner with others.  I’m skeptical that a couple that has only been together for a short amount of time has forged that bond.  Let’s face it, watching your partner fuck someone else and like it, can be tremendously arousing experience, but it can also be the opposite and elicit emotions that no one expected.  I believe that a strong relationship with a solid foundation and good communication skills can cope with the unexpected, and that a newer, less “mature” relationship may not.  Not that it can’t, but I think the odds are against it.  I’m sure that some of you may disagree with me, and I’m comfortable with that. 

Veronica:  I agree.  Look at the drama we had with Dina and Derek.  I think that the majority of that spawned from the fact that they had only been together for less than 2 years and just moved in together.   It takes a real sense of security with your partner to share.  I think that the security can take years to build.

If I knew this friend that is looking for a swinging partner-for-life, I don’t know what I’d tell him.  In fact, I’m skeptical that he’s looking for a swinging relationship at all.  It seems like he’s more interested in casual sex with multiple partners and not being committed to any of them. 

Veronica: I think he does want to have his cake and eat it too, having the perks of marriage and the perks of single men. If he really wants to find someone who might be open to the lifestyle I would suggest that he look for an active bi-woman.  I think that a woman who is going to want to have relationships with both men and women will be more open to the concept of an open relationship.

Back to one of my readers specific questions, swinging does seem to be more for the already-coupled, to borrow her phrase.  I repeated that search on Swappernet, this time for couples, and found 196 couples.  Which an optimistic single man would point out if more than the single men, so his odds of finding a single woman are theoretically better than than a couples!

One thing I should mention is that in our [limited] experience, there is a bias against single men.  Many profiles state “no single men” or “single men, don’t contact us, we’ll contact you if we’re interested” or something similar to that, and clubs and parties either don’t allow men at all or strictly limit the number of men who can attend a given event.  My feeling is that many swingers are like Veronica and I and see it as primarily a couple-centric activity.

Veronica: However, we always make an exception for a nice single woman.  Or two.

That’s my girl!!

============================================================================

As always, comments are more than welcome, especially fellow swingers or people in other forms of open relationships.  Am I off-base with my anti-young couple bias?  What are your thoughts on this man and his intentions?

I have a question from another reader about infidelity in the lifestyle, but part of me feels like I’ve been down that road before and don’t really have anything new to say, so I’m not sure if I want to go there again.  If you’re curious about previous posts on the topic, just put “infidelity” in the seach bar over there on the left, there are several posts to read!

  • http://suburbanwifeblogger.blogspot.com/ Suburban Hotwife

    WOW, a reader can miss A LOT if they don’t check back often and read additional comments on a post!

    I remember your post from last June, but I was unaware of the extensive debate that followed, and just as unaware of the broken friendship that ensued.

    This topic hits home for me as well, as a hotwife. I learned a term from a hw forum just recently – “faithful infidelity”. If I am interpreting your point of view correctly, Hubman, that is what you and Veronics practice, as do I in my situation.

    No, remind me to check back here to read follow ups, especially since i am the first person to comment!

  • Anonymous Reader

    Hi there! That was useful, thank you. :) I almost sent you a follow-up addressing what I thought might be one of your concerns. It seems like he’s thought about this a lot and I do believe it’s what he wants, not just having his cake and eating it too. He loves the idea of having one person to keep coming back to for the emotional connection. But I agree that he needs to find that person and get to a good spot with her before they start doing any of this stuff or it could get crazy (and not in a good, sexy way).

    I look forward to reading the comments later.

  • John and ann

    Reading this post and your earlier post this weekend about unicorns, I was reminded of our term for single guys–squirrels. Not nearly as mythical or rare as their female counterparts.

    Your post also raises serious issues, but for this Monday morning a little humor is in order.

    • http://hubmanshangout.wordpress.com/ hubman38

      I love ‘squirrels’, what a perfect term, I’m gonna have to remember that one!

      Sent from my iPhone

  • spin

    I have typed out three different sentences and just don’t know what to say.
    As you all know I mess around. Don’t plan to end the married. The ONLY thing it’s missing is sex. I can’t do without. And I thank those who are willing to help me out with my need. (-;

  • http://rtws.blogspot.com Emmy

    Totally not off base with the age thing. In fact, I have a post partially written about my feelings about it. :-)

    This story is pretty much the second story I’ve heard about a guy in a relationship cheating because he can’t have what he truly wants in the relationship – openness. Given this guy’s poor communication skills, I would suspect that swinging with a willing partner won’t work for him either. Sounds like he just needs to stay single.

    Swinging is a couples oriented activity. Single men are a dime a dozen as your little experiment demonstrate. We’ve found most single guys don’t read profiles, are pushy, and don’t take no for an answer. There are exceptions to the rule but those exceptions fight uphill battles against the majority.

  • T

    I would have to agree with you on this though I’ve never actively participated in the lifestyle. My ex-husband and I pondered the idea after 5 years of marriage. I definitely think there needs to be some sort of solid security in the primary relationship before checking into a lifestyle change.

    And for this guy? Yeah, a single bi-woman. Either way, it sounds like he needs to break things off with his current, and unfortunately, clueless-to-his-intentions girlfriend.

  • Southern Vixen

    Being a single woman in the swinging world, I am approached by A LOT of single guys. In the beginning of my swinging lifestyle, I was gullable and hooked up with a lot of single guys that were just looking for pussy and weren’t looking for the slightest bit of connection or friendship. I ended up getting burned. I learned to weed out the assholes by meeting guys that had “validations” by other couples that I had already be-friended. This has worked incredibly well for me.

    So, yes, single guys are welcome in the lifestyle, but they have to work 10X harder than the couples or single women. They are perceived as just horny guys looking for a piece of easy ass. But with the right circle of friends…they can be very desireable to others.

    • http://rtws.blogspot.com Emmy

      I think SoVix’s last sentence is very accurate with my experience as well. With the right circle of friends, they are quite desirable. :-)

  • Mike

    The main part of the question was how does the single man find a single lady open to the lifestyle. There are some websites (not sure if I should name it but think adult friends) out there that have more single ladies then a site set up for couple swinging. Those sites do have ladies that are more open minded about their sexual needs. It will not guarantee that they are open to sharing. Some ads will state that they are looking for extra but do not want the man with anyone else ( I know a double standard). I have always wondered if a single can really swing since by a mostly accepted definition swingers are couples who swap partners. But that statement could open a can of worms.

    On to the response to single men in the lifestyle. I have always felt that more couples are for swapping so that both partners have someone to be with. A single lady is accepted since what man does not want to see his lady with another lady. But in general they do not want to see her with another man. Thus couples do not look for a single man. Then you throw in all the stereotypes of the single man in the lifestyle out there (pushy, non respectful, creepy, etc) and even couples that like the MFM based threesomes are cautious when dealing with a single man. Then you have the whole fear of a single man trying to steal away the wife.

    I have found as a married man that is half way across the country from his wife that it took time to win favor with the local swingers community and part of that did not occur till after one of my wife’s visits where they were able to meet her. But it is possible to have success as a single man. As a side note when I am not geographically separated from my wife we play separately as well as a couple.

    Mike

  • http://playfullyyours.blogspot.com Playfully Yours

    When I was a single woman in the lifestyle it could be so great.

    I loved being with couples, since this was the best of both worlds for me. I got my need for a man and a woman, it was GREAT.

    The ‘single’ men I ran into were mostly married and cheating without consent (Big Turn Off).

    The actual single men I ran into were just wanting some quick booty and that was it. I wanted a steady sexual relationship to have fun with and experiment things with. It still makes me mad that these MEN still couldn’t just be honest. If I knew up front that they just wanted some booty then that was ok too. I enjoy a booty call too.

    I also noticed that the ‘single’ men were very aggressive (another Big Turn Off). For me, they sounded desperate and yes another turn off. I saw many couples that put up on their profiles….No single men and the single men still tried to contact them.

    I agree with Veronica, a bi woman is probably the best way to go. You have to be secure in your relationship to be in an open one as well. He doesn’t sound like one who wants to be honest about all that .

  • Anonymous Reader

    Lots of good responses, thanks everyone! I think he’s tried the adult friends website with not much luck, but the bi woman thing is a good idea.

    It’s actually funny that was mentioned because the only time I’ve ever seen him totally ass over heels for someone WAS a bi woman. They were great together but a combination of bad timing and a very long distance made a relationship impractical for both of them.

    • Anonymous Reader

      Well, I mean, ass over heels for someone besides himself… ;)

  • Anonymous

    I’m going for foreign woman. There are too many complexities with North American woman swinging or not. It is just too much time and money. I’m not a dater anyway. I prefer group cultures like the Brazilian or Italians. At least you can share the simpls things and not be so competitve.

   

Subscribe Via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner