Massachusetts is one of numerous states with a bottle deposit law. Since 1982 consumers have had to pay a nickel deposit on every bottle or can of beer or carbonated beverages, which they would get back when they returned the empty container.
Guess what happens with the deposit money that isn’t reclaimed by the consumer?
You guessed it, Massachusetts keeps every penny, $37 million in 2009. That’s 740 million cans and bottles!
I have no objection to recycling whatsoever, it’s the asinine way that this state goes about it and how they structure the system to NOT make it easy for the consumer, increasing the states revenue in the process. For starters, most communities already have curbside recycling for everything else- paper, cardboard, and other plastic and glass containers. We could do away with the deposit, the redemption machines, the time (and gas) to return bottles and cans, and still achieve the same goal.
What really makes it harder for the consumer to redeem bottles and cans for the deposit is how retailers are allowed to refuse to accept certain containers. Liquor stores don’t have to accept Coke or Pepsi cans or bottles if they don’t sell those items. Okay, I can understand that, if all you sell are items in glass or cans, you don’t want to deal with having a redemption machine for plastic as well. But it’s more than that.
We have 3 supermarkets in town, Hannafords, Stop&Shop and Shaws. Let’s say I buy a 12 pack of Pepsi Vanilla at Hannafords, then one day Veronica is going food shopping at Shaws and takes some empties with her to redeem while she’s there. Mixed in are some of the Pepsi Vanilla cans bought at Hannafords. If Shaws isn’t currently selling Pepsi Vanilla, they can refuse to accept those, even if they sell every other variation of Pepsi products on the market. Veronica now either has to bring those empties to another store, or just dump them in the trash can conveniently located nearby, rather than bring them back to the car before continuing with her shopping. I suspect that a great many people choose the latter and give the state a nickel for every bottle and can.
But wait, Massachusetts want to make it even better! Legislation was introduced earlier this year to EXPAND the bottle bill to include water, juice, energy drink and sport drink containers! Why continue to place these in the curbside recycle bins when they can collect a deposit, which they can keep, on all of those containers?
Think I’m being overly cynical? Check out this direct quote from the Massachusetts Recycling Coalition website about the proposed expansion of the bottle bill:
Would this help the state’s budget problems?
Yes. The state currently receives over $37 million per year in unclaimed deposits. It is expected that updating the Bottle Bill will generate an additional $15-20 million in revenue.
The state doesn’t give a shit about recycling, they want more of our money…
==========================================================================
You see what happens when Veronica isn’t here for a night? I start ranting about environmental policy!
Thankfully she’ll be back Sunday afternoon…